← Back to Podcast/Eric & Aaron: He Thought She Was Pulling Away… But The Real Reason Left Everyone Speechless
Episode Transcript

Eric & Aaron: He Thought She Was Pulling Away… But The Real Reason Left Everyone Speechless

What started with small changes in a three-year relationship quickly turned into one of the most emotional and unexpected To Catch a Cheater moments yet. From canceled future plans and suspicious behavior to a shocking confession nobody saw coming, this segment takes multiple turns before the truth finally comes out live on air. If you’re into relationship drama, cheating stories, emotional podcast moments, viral radio clips, love triangle confessions, and jaw-dropping relationship reveals, this episode will have you hooked from start to finish.

Think your partner might be up to something shady? The Jubal Show has you covered. In this explosive segment, The Jubal Show helps suspicious lovers uncover the truth by setting up the ultimate loyalty test. We call their significant other, posing as a grocery store’s floral department offering a free bouquet. You know.. a War of the Roses. The catch? Who they choose to send the flowers to—and what they write on the card—could reveal everything. Will it be a romantic gesture for their partner or a shocking betrayal? Get ready for twists, surprises, and jaw-dropping confrontations as we help our listeners get the answers they deserve. Subscribe to The Jubal Show's To Catch A Cheater / War of the Roses.

➡︎ Get on The Jubal Show with your story - https://thejubalshow.com

This is just a tiny piece of The Jubal Show. You can find every podcast we have, including the full show every weekday right here…

➡︎ https://thejubalshow.com/podcasts


The Jubal Show is everywhere, and also these places:

Support the show: https://the-jubal-show.beehiiv.com/subscribe

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Speaker 1: It's time to catch a Cheater. Only on the Jubile Show.

Speaker 2: Eric is on the phone today for to Catch a

Speaker 2: Cheater and he thinks that his girlfriend of three years

Speaker 2: might be messing around. So in a few minutes, we'll

Speaker 2: call her and see if we can figure it out

Speaker 2: for him. But first, Eric, why do you think your

Speaker 2: girlfriend Aaron might be cheating?

Speaker 1: Well, we've been together for a few years now, and

Speaker 1: up until like six months ago, it has honestly been great.

Speaker 1: We've been very close. We were talking about getting a

Speaker 1: dog kind of that was kind of my first clue.

Speaker 1: When she started cooling off on the dog idea, I

Speaker 1: was like, why what it seemed like we were progressing,

Speaker 1: you know, So that that made me start just kind

Speaker 1: of paying attention and realizing, Oh. The next thing I

Speaker 1: noticed was she's someone she loves talking about how she

Speaker 1: has cute outfits and casual outfits, and you know, cute

Speaker 1: outfits are for going out, casual outfits are for being

Speaker 1: at home relaxing, and she works from home sometimes and

Speaker 1: so but then she would wear cute outfits while she

Speaker 1: was working from home. Maybe that sounds weird. I for me,

Speaker 1: that was a that was like a change right. That

Speaker 1: was like something is different here, and okay, we have

Speaker 1: this uh one of our one of our friends who

Speaker 1: I've known longer than her, h she started kind of

Speaker 1: acting weird around me. It made me think that like

Speaker 1: like she knows something. You can just kind of get

Speaker 1: a vibe with people, you know, Like she didn't want

Speaker 1: to be around me because she she felt like she

Speaker 1: knew something is is the impression that I got from it.

Speaker 1: And if one if it was just one of these things,

Speaker 1: I'm sorry, I'm sorry, I'm just emotional at all. I

Speaker 1: just if it was just one of these things, it

Speaker 1: wouldn't be a big deal. But because it's all of

Speaker 1: these things, it it makes me worried. Yeah, And if

Speaker 1: you know your partner, you can tell when something's wrong

Speaker 1: right after weeks of like what is going on? Right,

Speaker 1: Like if someone wants to talk to you, they'll try

Speaker 1: to talk to you. And I feel like I've lost

Speaker 1: that with her.

Speaker 2: All right, Well, you already told us a grocery store,

Speaker 2: she's a rewards card my Brett. So we'll play a

Speaker 2: songcome back and then call her and pretend to be

Speaker 2: from the grocery store and say that every single month

Speaker 2: we choose one Lucky Reward member who gets free flowers

Speaker 2: delivered from our floral department, and we'll see if she

Speaker 2: sends those to you or to somebody else, Okay, instead.

Speaker 1: Of if she If you say flowers, she might send

Speaker 1: it to her mom or something I could you say

Speaker 1: like whiskey or something like that. She I'm a big

Speaker 1: whiskey guy. She would definitely think of me if you

Speaker 1: said whiskey specifically.

Speaker 2: Okay, yep, we can figure something out like that. If

Speaker 2: you're just joining us for today's to Catch Cheater. Eric

Speaker 2: is on the phone and he thinks that his girlfriend

Speaker 2: three years named Aaron might be messing around. So we're

Speaker 2: about to call her and pretend to be from the

Speaker 2: grocery store where she's a rewards member and say that

Speaker 2: Every single month we choose one lucky Reward member who

Speaker 2: gets a free gift from us, and this month it's

Speaker 2: flowers and a bottle of whiskey to special somebody in

Speaker 2: her life, which hopefully she'll send to her boyfriend Eric.

Speaker 2: But she sends it to someone else, then we'll know

Speaker 2: that she might be messing around. But before we do that, Eric,

Speaker 2: why don't you break down your situation for us again

Speaker 2: real quick.

Speaker 1: Yeah. We've been together for three years and I feel

Speaker 1: like they're like, we're not communicating like we were. She

Speaker 1: started like dressing up nice at times that I was

Speaker 1: surprising one of her, one of like our both of

Speaker 1: our close friends, Ellie. She's been weird around me lately,

Speaker 1: like she knows something that I don't and doesn't want

Speaker 1: to have to lie to me or something. So yeah,

Speaker 1: all right, are you ready for us to call her? Yeah, okay,

Speaker 1: here we go.

Speaker 2: Hello, Hey, this is Corbett calling for I was looking

Speaker 2: for our Rewards Card member named Aaron. Yeah, that's me, Hi, Aaron.

Speaker 2: How are you please don't hang up. This is not

Speaker 2: a marketing phone call. I'm actually calling with a big congratulations.

Speaker 2: Here this month's winner.

Speaker 3: Oh okay, cool. I didn't know that you guys were

Speaker 3: giving away stuff.

Speaker 2: Oh yeah, maybe, well, maybe you don't know. Every single month,

Speaker 2: we choose one of our Rewards Card members at random

Speaker 2: to call and give a free gift to, and this

Speaker 2: month it's flowers delivered from our florial department, as well

Speaker 2: as the flavor of the month. If it's for somebody

Speaker 2: over twenty one, it's also a bottle of bullet bourbon

Speaker 2: that will be delivering as well to a special someone

Speaker 2: in your life absolutely free. It's actually a three hundred

Speaker 2: and sixteen dollars values thirty six Longsi red roses, box

Speaker 2: of candy or chocolate, the bottle of bourbon, and a card.

Speaker 4: Okay, I never win anything.

Speaker 2: Well, now you can't say that anymore. The first thing

Speaker 2: that I would need would be the first and last

Speaker 2: name of the person you'd like to send them to,

Speaker 2: and then if you want to put anything on a card,

Speaker 2: and then we have the address and that's it.

Speaker 3: Okay, So I see I'm gonna go with Is it

Speaker 3: like all of the above or.

Speaker 1: Just the flowers or it's all of the above?

Speaker 4: Okay, perfect? All right? So the person I want to

Speaker 4: send them to, Ellie.

Speaker 2: Okay, got that, Ellie, Ellie? And then do you want

Speaker 2: to add a note along with it?

Speaker 4: Yeah?

Speaker 3: Okay, I know you are being very patient. I'll tell

Speaker 3: him soon. We'll make it up for you tonight.

Speaker 1: Got that. Okay? Great?

Speaker 2: And at this point, Aaron, I'm going to let you

Speaker 2: know that this is actually a radio show. It's called

Speaker 2: the Jewbell Show.

Speaker 1: Yeah, Hi, Erin, I'm Nina.

Speaker 2: Hi, I'm Victoria, and my name is Jeubll And we

Speaker 2: do a segment on our show that's called to Catch

Speaker 2: a Cheater, where if you think your significant other might

Speaker 2: be messing around you see you they send flowers to

Speaker 2: and your boyfriend of three years, Eric is on the phone.

Speaker 1: Yeah, I'm I'm here, Aaron. What you're sending flowers to? Ellie?

Speaker 3: I guess I can still say that I never want anything.

Speaker 3: I can't believe you're on the phone. I did not

Speaker 3: think that it would happen like this.

Speaker 1: Yeah, what are you supposed to tell me?

Speaker 4: I don't. I don't want to tell you anything.

Speaker 3: I mean, I just I didn't think it would happen

Speaker 3: like this, Like this is not what you think it is.

Speaker 1: You didn't you didn't think what would happen like this?

Speaker 1: How was this not what I'm what I think it is?

Speaker 1: If well, I could tell you about this off the phone,

Speaker 1: like I've tried to talk with you about this. We've

Speaker 1: I've tried. This was the best.

Speaker 4: I don't think you have tried. You never listened to me.

Speaker 4: You don't know what I'm going through. You have no idea.

Speaker 3: And Ellie's like a really good friend who's been like

Speaker 3: a shoulder for me. The last couple of months, you know,

Speaker 3: like I'm going through a lot at work.

Speaker 1: We've been together for years now, Why can't you just

Speaker 1: tell me what's going on.

Speaker 4: I am trying to, but you're not even listening. You

Speaker 4: never listen to me.

Speaker 3: I do have to work late, and then I was

Speaker 3: gonna stop by Ellie's just for a bit, like I

Speaker 3: just don't understand, like we are friends, and I.

Speaker 1: Why about it? Why lie about it? Then?

Speaker 4: Why lie about what? She's my friend?

Speaker 1: You were working late, I know, but then why why

Speaker 1: wouldn't you come home after that?

Speaker 4: I just stopped.

Speaker 3: So Ellie and I have gotten a lot closer lately,

Speaker 3: and I didn't know how to tell you because it

Speaker 3: kind of just happened. I didn't plan it, and I

Speaker 3: kind of didn't know what was happening. But I have

Speaker 3: feelings for her, and I was going to tell you soon,

Speaker 3: but that's kind of what the card meant. Well, yeah,

Speaker 3: I know, how back, Ellie, I.

Speaker 4: Know, and Eric, I didn't. I didn't want it to

Speaker 4: come out like this.

Speaker 3: I didn't want you to find out on a radio

Speaker 3: show where I thought I won something.

Speaker 1: Absolutely, you guys, this is insane.

Speaker 3: I just it started as friends and then we started

Speaker 3: seeing each other and then we like the feelings developed,

Speaker 3: and then I didn't know what the difference between being

Speaker 3: best friends and being like intimate was.

Speaker 1: Kind of I thought we were best friends.

Speaker 4: I mean, I care about you, I let you, I.

Speaker 1: Do love building.

Speaker 3: Have you ever been in the situation before? Have you

Speaker 3: ever fell in love with your best friend? It's a

Speaker 3: little confusing, have.

Speaker 1: You have you ever been in my situation? How are

Speaker 1: you falling in love with somebody? When you're we were

Speaker 1: gonna get a dog? We were, we lived together. Not

Speaker 1: even you're saying this is a great area? What is

Speaker 1: great about my best friend? Eric?

Speaker 3: Like, I don't know how to explain this to you,

Speaker 3: but just one day we were like hanging out and

Speaker 3: watching movies, and then one dayhere we were kissing.

Speaker 4: And it's kind of confusing.

Speaker 3: And I didn't know when keating began and friendship ended

Speaker 3: in all of the above, and I had to kind

Speaker 3: of figure that out. And I can have both of

Speaker 3: you in my ear, and I'm sorry, but I do

Speaker 3: have feelings for her, And this is exactly what I knew.

Speaker 3: What would happen is you'd be like, oh, we're you

Speaker 3: need a dog? I have a life too.

Speaker 1: Of course, this is what happened.

Speaker 4: What do you mean what would happen?

Speaker 3: Yeah, you're gonna convince me to stay with you like

Speaker 3: you always do, and sometimes I want to live my

Speaker 3: life and Ellie's.

Speaker 4: Supportive of that.

Speaker 1: Convince you. Why would you even think I would want

Speaker 1: to be with you after this. It's not just that

Speaker 1: you had feelings, right, you acted on them. Oh my god,

Speaker 1: with a friend. Imagine if I did this to a

Speaker 1: friend of ours. Imagine if I just started dating somebody

Speaker 1: that we knew behind your back. You're saying this, I.

Speaker 3: Don't know, areting you never get anything. You don't understand.

Speaker 3: We didn't just start dating. We have been really good

Speaker 3: friends and then all of a sudden feelings developed. And

Speaker 3: it kind of also wasn't all of a sudden. It

Speaker 3: wasn't a switch. There's not a switch that's like on

Speaker 3: and off. It just happened.

Speaker 1: You know what this you Aaron? I'm sorry, I'm sorry

Speaker 1: if I can't say that. Thank you guys for for

Speaker 1: doing this and having me. I'm so sorry. I'm I

Speaker 1: just I have to go. This is I'm gonna call

Speaker 1: my mom, but you will show to catch a cheater

This transcript was automatically generated by the podcast creator and may contain errors. Aggregated via the PodcastIndex API.